Html Codes

followers

Translate

follow by email

Monday, 9 June 2014

An attempt to understand Arnold's "The Study of Poetry"

Matthew Arnold’s The Study of Poetry stands as a guide for the readers to understand the intricacies of poetry, and differentiating classic poetry and merely good poetry. He begins his essay by stating that it is poetry which has always stood the test of times and firmly. And as time goes on, poetry “will find an ever surer and surer stay”. When religion fails to instruct us, poetry continues to instruct us for poetry attaches its emotion to the idea; and the fact is the idea for poetry. According to Arnold, if religion exists today, then it is only because of its “unconscious poetry”.

Arnold then talks about the role of poetry - that poetry is there to interpret life for us and that is the anchor of lives, its primary and the most significant role is “to console us, to sustain us”. Science too does not exist without poetry, for the impassioned expression behind science has to be poetry. Wordsworth calls poetry “the breath and finer spirit of all knowledge”. It is not any other branch of science that can regard itself as the best knowledge provider, except for poetry which rightly plumes itself in this case.

Arnold comments on how poetry must be judged. Since, poetry itself is of high order and excellence, it is reasonable to have a high standard and strict judgment. This quality criticism will enable us, the readers, to conceive highly of the destinies of poetry than we ought to conceive of it on a surface level. In the stream of poetry where art and thought is one, there shall not be any entrance for charlatanism according to Arnold. A charlatan is someone who pretends to have more knowledge or skills than he actually possesses; and we may find such people in politics and in the government but definitely not in poetry. Charlatanism is for confusing, it differentiates between “excellent and inferior, sound and unsound or half-sound, true and untrue or only half-true” and this is not permitted in poetry because all the mentioned qualities are of supreme importance – which again is because of the high destinies of poetry.

Arnold calls poetry a “criticism of life” – this statement is based on an old Socratic principle where criticism of life is done by the laws of poetic truth and poetic beauty; this alone sustains the spiritual moorings of the human race. Poetry, here, is seen as a sustaining power because it is the reflection or the meaning of life and also that it conveys “excellent”, “sound” and “truth” out of the paramount qualities mentioned. The best poetry has the power of forming, sustaining and delighting us.

According to Arnold, when we judge any piece of poetry, we are constantly swayed by two fallacious estimates, the historical and the personal estimate. While Arnold wants us to judge the art work by using the real estimate. A historic estimate is one where the reader regards a poet’s work as a stage in the course of development, therefore, one tends to estimate highly of the work than the greatness it actually possesses. While a personal estimate is based on personal affinities and likings that the reader attributes to the poet and this has a great power to sway one’s estimate. Arnold emphasizes on making a real estimate where a sense for the best and excellent, which gives strength and joy, becomes the reader’s main gain. This should “govern” the reader’s estimate of what he reads.

Arnold speaks of the different types of poets and how they must be assessed – if the poet is a doubtful classic, then he must be separated from his coarse parts; if the poet is a false classic, then he must be exploded (his works must be ignored); and if the poet is a real classic, then one must feel and enjoy his work as deeply as ever. The use of a negative criticism must only be done in order to enable us to have a clearer sense and a deeper enjoyment of what is truly excellent.

According to Arnold, a work of poetry is termed classic when it has the power to delight, instruct, console and sustain us. And the poetic quality is assessed through imbibing the touchstone method. The touchstone refers to the deep study of classics and an “infallible touchstone (is required) for detecting the presence or absence of high poetic quality”. The superiority of poetry over history must and should possess a higher truth and higher seriousness; that these two come from absolute sincerity.

In conclusion, Arnold speaks of good literature as one which might lose its supremacy but not currency. This currency is not present through world’s deliberate conscious choice, but by something far deeper, sublime – “by the instinct of self-preservation in humanity”.

"POETRY IS SIMPLY THE MOST BEAUTIFUL, IMPRESSIVE, AND WIDELY EFFECTIVE MODE OF SAYING THINGS."
- MATTHEW ARNOLD

No comments:

Post a Comment

I would love to hear from you! Do leave a comment!

books

  • Alan Sillitoe - THE LONELINESS OF THE LONG DISTANCE RUNNER
  • Albert Camus - THE STRANGER
  • Aldous Huxley - CROME YELLOW
  • Aldous Huxley - THE BRAVE NEW WORLD
  • Alex Huxley - ROOTS
  • Amitav Ghosh - SHADOW LINES
  • Amitav Ghosh - THE GREAT DERANGEMENT: CLIMATE CHANGE AND THE UNTHINKABLE
  • Amy Tan - THE JOY LUCK CLUB
  • Andrew Sanders - THE SHORT OXFORD HISTORY OF ENGLISH LITERATURE
  • Anna Sewell - BLACK BEAUTY
  • Anonymous - BEAUTY AND THE BEAST
  • Anton Chekhov - THE CHERRY ORCHARD
  • Anton Chekhov - THE SEA GULL
  • Anton Chekhov - THE THREE SISTERS
  • Anton Chekhov - UNCLE VANYA
  • Arthur Miller - ALL MY SONS
  • Arthur Miller - DEATH OF A SALESMAN
  • Arun Joshi - THE STRANGE CASE OF BILLY BISWAS
  • Bapsi Sidhwa - ICE-CANDY MAN
  • Ben Mezrich - THE ACCIDENTAL BILLIONAIRES
  • Bernhard Schlink - THE READER
  • Bill Watterson - CALVIN AND HOBBES
  • Billy Arjan Singh - TIGER HAVEN
  • Billy Arjan Singh - WATCHING INDIA'S WILDLIFE: THE ANTHOLOGY OF A LIFETIME
  • Boris Pasternak - DOCTOR ZHIVAGO
  • Brian L. Weiss - MANY LIVES, MANY MASTERS
  • Charles Dickens - HARD TIMES
  • Charlotte Bronte - JANE EYRE
  • Charlotte Perkins Gilman - THE YELLOW WALLPAPER
  • Chitra Divakaruni - PALACE OF ILLUSIONS
  • Christopher Marlowe - THE TRAGICAL HISTORY OF DOCTOR FAUSTUS
  • D.H. Lawrence - THE RAINBOW
  • D.V. Gundappa - MANKUTHIMMANNA KAGGA
  • Daniel Glattauer - EVERY SEVENTH WAVE
  • Daniel Glattauer - LOVE VIRTUALLY
  • Daniel Klein and Thomas Gathcart - PLATO AND A PLATYPUS WALK INTO A BAR
  • Dante Alighieri - THE DIVINE COMEDY
  • David Malouf - FLY AWAY PETER
  • Dev Anand - ROMANCING WITH LIFE
  • Doug Johnstone - GONE AGAIN
  • Ernest Hemingway - A MOVABLE FEAST
  • Ernest Hemingway - THE OLD MAN AND THE SEA
  • Eugene O'Neill - LONG DAY'S JOURNEY INTO NIGHT
  • Euripides - THE TROJAN WOMEN
  • F. Scott Fitzgerald - THE GREAT GATSBY
  • Flora Rheta Schreiber - SYBIL
  • Franz Kafka - THE TRIAL
  • Friedrich Nietzsche - BEYOND GOOD AND EVIL
  • Friedrich Nietzsche - THE DAWN OF THE DAY
  • Friedrich Nietzsche - THUS SPAKE ZARATHUSTRA
  • Fyodor Dostoyevsky - CRIME AND PUNISHMENT
  • Geoffrey C. Ward, Diane Raines Ward - TIGER-WALLAHS: SAVING THE GREATEST OF THE GREAT CATS
  • George Lamming - IN THE CASTLE OF MY SKIN
  • George Orwell - 1984
  • George Orwell - ANIMAL FARM
  • George William Erskine Russell - MATTHEW ARNOLD
  • Giriprakash K. - THE STORY OF VIJAY MALLYA
  • Girish Karnad - BOILED BEANS ON TOAST
  • Girish Karnad - FIRE AND RAIN
  • Girish Karnad - HAYAVADANA
  • Girish Karnad - NAGAMANDALA
  • Girish Karnad - TUGHLAQ
  • Greg Garrard - ECOCRITICISM
  • Gustave Flaubert - MADAME BOVARY
  • Henrik Ibsen - A DOLL'S HOUSE
  • Henrik Ibsen - AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE
  • Homer - THE ILIAD
  • Hugh Allen - THE LONELY TIGER
  • I. A. Richards - PRINCIPLES OF LITERARY CRITICISM
  • J.C. Martin - THE DOLL
  • J.D. Salinger - THE CATCHER IN THE RYE
  • J.E. Carrington Turner - MANEATERS AND MEMORIES
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE CHAMBER OF SECRETS
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE CURSED CHILD
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE DEADLY HALLOWS
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE GOBLET OF FIRE
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE HALF-BLOOD PRINCE
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE ORDER OF THE PHOENIX
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE PHILOSOPHER'S STONE
  • J.K. Rowling - HARRY POTTER AND THE PRISONER OF AZKABAN
  • J.M. Coetzee - DISGRACE
  • J.M. Synge - RIDERS TO THE SEA
  • Jack London - THE CALL OF THE WILD
  • James Herriot - ALL CREATURES GREAT AND SMALL
  • James Herriot - ALL THINGS BRIGHT AND BEAUTIFUL
  • James Herriot - ALL THINGS WISE AND WONDERFUL
  • James Herriot - EVERY LIVING THING
  • James Herriot - THE LORD GOD MADE THEM ALL
  • James Joyce - ULYSSES
  • James Redfield - THE CELESTINE PROPHECY
  • James Redfield - THE SECRET OF SHAMBHALA: IN SEARCH OF THE ELEVENTH INSIGHT
  • James Redfield - THE TENTH INSIGHT: HOLDING THE VISION
  • James Redfield, Michael Murphy, Sylvia Timbers - GOD AND THE EVOLVING UNIVERSE
  • Jerome - THREE MEN IN A BOAT
  • Jim Corbett - MAN-EATERS OF KUMAON
  • John Berger - WHY LOOK AT ANIMALS?
  • John Green - THE FAULT IN OUR STARS
  • Jonathan Swift - THE BATTLE OF THE BOOKS
  • Jonnathan Christ - A PLACE CALLED ZERO
  • Kalidasa - RITUSAMHARA
  • Kenneth Anderson - TALES FROM THE INDIAN JUNGLE
  • Kenneth Anderson - THE CALL OF THE MAN-EATER
  • Kenneth Anderson - THE TIGER ROARS
  • Khaled Hosseini - A THOUSAND SPLENDID SUNS
  • Khaled Hosseini - AND THE MOUNTAINS ECHOED
  • Khaled Hosseini - THE KITE RUNNER
  • Khushwant Singh - TRAIN TO PAKISTAN
  • Maduri Banerjee - LOSING MY VIRGINITY AND OTHER DUMB IDEAS
  • Mahasweta Devi - DRAUPADI
  • Mahasweta Devi - MOTHER OF 1084
  • Mahesh Dattani - DANCE LIKE A MAN
  • Mahesh Dattani - THE FINAL SOLUTIONS
  • Mahesh Dattani - WHERE THERE IS A WILL
  • Malsawmi Jacob - ZORAMI
  • Marc Riboud - I FOR IMAGINE
  • Markus Zusak - THE BOOK THIEF
  • Max Porter - GRIEF IS THE THING WITH FEATHERS
  • Melina Marchetta - LOOKING FOR ALIBRANDI
  • Michael Ondaatje - THE ENGLISH PATIENT
  • Monique Douglass-Andrews - FROM GHETTO TO GLORY
  • Nagarajan M. S. - ENGLISH LITERARY CRITICISM AND THEORY: AN INTRODUCTORY HISTORY
  • Naman Ramachandran - RAJINIKANTH: THE DEFINITIVE BIOGRAPHY
  • Naseeruddin Shah - AND THEN ONE DAY: A MEMOIR
  • Oscar Wilde - A WOMAN OF NO IMPORTANCE
  • Oscar Wilde - LADY WINDERMERE'S FAN
  • Oscar Wilde - THE NIGHTINGALE AND THE ROSE
  • Oscar Wilde - THE SELFISH GIANT
  • Pam Morris - REALISM
  • Paul Cobley - NARRATIVE
  • Paulo Coelho - BY THE RIVER PIEDRA I SAT DOWN AND WEPT
  • Paulo Coelho - INSPIRATIONS
  • Paulo Coelho - THE ALCHEMIST
  • Paulo Coelho - THE PILGRIMAGE
  • Perumal Murugan - ONE PART WOMAN
  • R.K. Narayan - THE ENGLISH TEACHER
  • Raja Rao - KANTHAPURA
  • Ramchandra Guha - DEMOCRATS AND DISSENTERS
  • Ramchandra Guha - INDIA AFTER GANDHI
  • Randy Pausch - THE LAST LECTURE
  • Richard Branson - LOSING MY VIRGINITY
  • Richard Brinsley Sheridan - THE SCHOOL FOR SCANDAL
  • Richard Dawkins - THE GOD DELUSION
  • Robert Fulghum - ALL I REALLY NEED TO KNOW I LEARNED IN KINDERGARTEN
  • Robin Waterfield - THE GREEK MYTHS
  • Roland Barthes - MYTHOLOGIES
  • Rudyard Kipling - THE JUNGLE BOOK
  • Ruskin Bond - A FLIGHT OF PIGEONS
  • Ruskin Bond - ANGRY RIVER
  • Ruskin Bond - CHERRY TREE
  • Ruskin Bond - CHILDREN'S OMNIBUS
  • Ruskin Bond - DELHI IS NOT FAR
  • Ruskin Bond - LANDOUR DAYS
  • Ruskin Bond - RAIN IN THE MOUNTAINS
  • Ruskin Bond - RUSTY RUNS AWAY
  • Ruskin Bond - RUSTY, THE BOY FROM THE HILLS
  • Ruskin Bond - THE BLUE UMBRELLA
  • Ruskin Bond - THE HIDDEN POOL
  • Ruskin Bond - THE LAMP IS LIT
  • Ruskin Bond - THE ROOM ON THE ROOF
  • S. L. Bhyrappa - AVARANA: THE VEIL
  • Salman Rushdie - MIDNIGHT'S CHILDREN
  • Salman Rushdie - THE SATANIC VERSES
  • Sandeep Balakrishna - TIPU SULTAN: THE TYRANT OF MYSORE
  • Santosh Avvannavar, Dr. Shayan Haq - SHE: EKLA CHOLO RE
  • Santosh Avvannavar, Meena R. Chandawarkar - UMBILICAL CORD
  • Santosh Avvannavar, Shilpa Patil - SURROGATE AUTHOR
  • Sarah Abochacker - BREAKING TIES
  • Shashi Deshpande - THAT LONG SILENCE
  • Shinie Antony - THE ORPHANAGE FOR WORDS
  • Sidney Sheldon - TELL ME YOUR DREAMS
  • Sigmund Freud - INTERPRETATION OF DREAMS
  • Sophocles - OEDIPUS REX
  • Stephen Hawking - A BRIEF HISTORY OF TIME
  • Swapan Seth - THIS IS ALL I HAVE TO SAY
  • T.S. Eliot - MURDER IN THE CATHEDRAL
  • T.S. Eliot - THE COCKTAIL PARTY
  • Temsula Ao - THESE HILLS CALLED HOME: STORIES FROM A WAR ZONE
  • Tennesee Williams - THE GLASS MENAGERIE
  • Thomas Hardy - TESS OF THE D'URBERVILLES
  • Thomas R. Flynn - EXISTENTIALISM
  • Toni Morrison - A MERCY
  • Toni Morrison - BELOVED
  • Toni Morrison - DESDEMONA
  • Toni Morrison - HOME
  • Toni Morrison - JAZZ
  • Toni Morrison - PARADISE
  • Toni Morrison - PLAYING IN THE DARK
  • Toni Morrison - SONG OF SOLOMON
  • Toni Morrison - SULA
  • Toni Morrison - TAR BABY
  • Toni Morrison - THE BIG BOX
  • Toni Morrison - THE BLUEST EYE
  • Toni Morrison - THE DANCING MIND
  • Twinkle Khanna - MRS FUNNYBONES
  • U. R. Ananthmurthy - SAMSKARA
  • Ullas Karanth - A VIEW FROM THE MACHAN
  • Ullas Karanth - THE WAY OF THE TIGER
  • Valmik Thapar - THE SECRET LIFE OF TIGERS
  • Valmik Thapar - TIGER FIRE
  • Vikram Seth - BEASTLY TALES FROM HERE AND THERE
  • Vincent Bivona - HOUSE OF JUSTICE: A HORROR SHORT STORY
  • Virgil - AENEID
  • Walter Farley - THE BLACK STALLION
  • William Henry Hudson - AN OUTLINE HISTORY OF ENGLISH LITERATURE
  • William Shakespeare - JULIUS CAESAR
  • William Shakespeare - MACBETH
  • William Shakespeare - OTHELLO
  • William Shakespeare - THE MERCHANT OF VENICE
  • William Shakespeare - THE TEMPEST
  • Zak Ebrahim - THE TERRORIST'S SON: A STORY OF CHOICE

most viewed blogposts

google+ followers